How Citizen Journalism elected President Trump

11 Nov. 2016 - - Total Reads 7,406

Citizen Journalism


The Online Underdog
How Citizen Journalism elected President Trump

As an Aussie, I love an underdog story. In the US election I think we witnessed two. Mid last year I finished marathoning ESPN’s 20 for 20 documentaries and started to be pulled into the presidential race. I’ve been watching closely for over a year now, interested in how the story would conclude, and shocked, not in the result, but how it unfolded. As a marketer, I was swept up in the story, the campaign and the players, especially the new Citizen Media, or Citizen Journalism Movement. As a engineer, I was engrossed in the numbers, the stats and the data unfolding online. What a show.

I watched a piece around a week before the election on how to win the Presidency, from a Washington insider. He said something that resonated with me and rings true for all successful marketing campaigns. You need to tick these 3 boxes well;

  1. The Money

  2. The Organisation

  3. The Message

In marketing, often the one’s with more money and a better organisation can easily out play the message. But in the case of this election, two candidates spent less and started well behind in the organisation front, but delivered a message that aligned with movements waiting to happen. That alignment is the key to the success of every product, don’t educate people on what they should buy, align with what they want.

I’m and advocate of innovation and disruption; I posted last year on Facebook I would have loved to see two outliers contend the election, Bernie v. Trump. And watching Sanders brilliant trajectory in the primaries, I was shocked alongside his supporters when Clinton won the nomination. She had the better Organisation behind her, but with Trump, well, the day before the election, he was a 1% chance on the most respected polls worldwide.

Trump and his supporters succeeded against these odds and more. From a digital marketing and software vantage point, I was shocked at the things I saw during the race they overcame. For my research I had setup my feeds, searches and interest as moderate, with a like both or incognito position, to gather a raw as possible feed from both Clinton and Trump’s lenses. So here are my top 10 reasons I think this will go down as the greatest underdog story of my lifetime ;

  1. Main Stream Media (MSM). Watch any major program (or read any article) and aside from a few like Fox, the left had Hillary winning every hour up until the last. The thing to note here from the Aussie point of view, was the left filter on Trump was huge and likely why we are seeing such shock on across our feeds of the result.
  1. Google. As a corporation they can do what ever they like to their algorithm and I support their business choices. But when I tried to search for negative Clinton sites, or positive Trump sites, often I was surprised at the results. Predictive search included. Bing by comparison; no noticeable bias.
  1. YouTube. You’d think with millions more views on the same day, videos would trend to the front page. Did he make it once ? I didn’t check everyday, but I didn’t see it happen.
  1. Facebook, same as Google, Mark Z and co have every right to change his trending algorithm and search results to support Clinton. I rarely saw a negative Clinton trend in the default or politics feeds and where milliseconds count in search results, Trump was far harder to find. Also I saw plenty of comments with less likes and shares elevated to the top of posts if they were pro Clinton.
  1. Twitter. Ditto. Except the amount of people posting on the platform was enormously Pro Trump. The Clinton feed look positive unless you clicked into any response to a tweet – then it was chaos.
  1. Reddit. This was a real surprise. I started following r/S4P and saw Sanders blow up, but nothing like the upvotes on r/The_Donald when he started to dominate the front page and the next pages of /All. Algorithms were changed (probably fair enough or Reddit would have been a Trump show for the last 6 months). Comparative Stats here
  1. Polls – Pollsters – Do they still have businesses ? If I gave advice that was 99% wrong everyday for 6 months, I’d be out of business.
  1. DDoS Attacks – Among other’s targeted Wikileaks is primary here but not the only site to suffer disruption to their service. Some very fishy stuff was going down including a worldwide peek before the election of attacks originating from and to the USA (highly unusual).
  2. Pull the Plug! … Wikileaks was attacked from multiple angles – so much so the platform started releasing private key’s (locks to their backup leaks) as Assange’s internet was cut off at the Ecuadorian embassy under pressure from the White House.
  1. Spend. When you spend more, you have greater reach, there are numbers out there showing Trump spent a fraction of others in the primaries, and I hear about a third of Clinton per vote in the election.

How Did Citizen Journalism Overcome these Barriers ?

How did the Trump supporters overcome all of this? To me it comes down to one thing, people power. Against these odds they found nimble ways to share Trumps message online. This amazed me as I watched advocacy build new pathways and cobble together connectivity of small blogs, social profiles and YouTube channels into juggernauts claiming tens to hundreds of millions of more eyeballs than the MSM. Citizen Journalism is now a major and recognised force online. If you are building a brand online, know your advocates are your greatest asset.

Ok some big digital rules – First if your message is organic, it resonates strongly, if it feels over produced it does not. While at often times raw, I’ve never seen a better execution of this than Trump’s campaign. This is the reason Correct The Record and other well funded pro Clinton outlets, even with the scales tipped in their favour, could not cut through the pro Trump advocacy. Second big no-no online – if you have a page or profile, leave all comments up and respond, good or bad, otherwise it looks like you are hiding from the truth. There are a few exceptions to this, for example if the user has posted language which is not aligned to your audience. Remember though, a blocked user is still promoting, louder, to more people, just not on your page. You’ve surrendered your chance to convince them otherwise.

I’m keen to watch the data unfold from here. Will those channels and challenges above balance out their platforms? Some have already. Will they change the historical data to reflect a non-bias position, if they can they likely will. My prediction, smart traffic and algorithms will drop the bias. At the same time, I credit American’s as far smarter than the stereotype, and together will find common ground.

As for the message – If Trump never entered politics and ruthlessly made more money (or lost it) – he would have likely gotten more egotistical and more arrogant until his hair took over his head 🙂 His twitter sure would have been an interesting ride… He inherits @POTUS soon! But this is a big pivot for Trump – essentially trumping any ego or competitive measuring sticks I imagine billionaires compare themselves with. He could leave the planet either folding his fortune, ruining the very definition “Trump”. Or as the optimist in me hopes, this political underdog will continue to shock everyone, tune his message and leave a legacy as one of the greats.

Michael Simonetti
Posted by:

Post Reads: 7.4K

Share this
Comments
Jack Brukarz Said :
"A man after my own heart. Great analysis. I am absolutely convinced that the left wing bias in journalism and media runs the world."
Michael Simonetti Said :
"I think they run some of the world, the scale is tipping into the hands of bloggers and new media startups though; Eg. Breitbart recorded 200 Million pageviews in September, Fox, MSNBC and CNN did UNDER 20 Million viewers in Primetime Combined!"

Trusted by

NextTech
Victorian Government
Eway
Hanover
Loan Market
Acquia Certified Site Builder Drupal
Shell
Focus On Furniture
Matchbox Homewares
Engineers Without Borders
Oracle
CAN- Common Wealth Bank
QV Skincare
Melbourne Heart
Magento Solution Specialist
Think & Grow Rich Inc
Plan It Sync It
Elucent
Madman Entertainment
Arthur Galan
POSTER Magazine
Bulk Nutrients
Sports Power
Oakdale Meat Co
WTFN
Craft CMS
Ego Pharmaceuticals
Engine Swim
Sunday Creek
Bintani Australia
Fresh Cheese Company
Naturtint
Royal Freemasons
Unsw Australia
Toy World
RMIT University
Toni&Guy
OJAY
Macmillan Publishing
Boston Consulting Group
Kay&Burton
ADP Payroll
Metricon
iPrimus
Cleanfit
Van Egmond Group
Buy Aussie Now
Peter Mac
Passage Foods
VISSF
Celebrate Health
NMI Insurance
Adobe Professional
Heat Holders
Bostik
Jalna
Uber
Max’s
Wild Rhino Shoes
DepSkin.com
Cronos Australia
Fairfax Media
Aqium Gel
SMH – The Sydney Morning Herald
Switzer Media+Publishing
News
Parker Lane
Grainshaker
PranaOn
Federation Square
Bank of Cyprus
DeeWhy Market
Tomorrow Stars Basketball
Dinosaur Designs
Schiavello
Grays Ecommerce
Australian Government
Rydges
McArthur Skincare
Maxine
Watches of Switzerland
Australian Physiotherapy Association
White Suede
TPP
The Burger Cheese
Amino Active
Australian Organic Food CO
Natralus Australia
One Shift
Cell Therapies
Melrose MCT
Jetstar
Bondi Sands
Vendor Advocacy Australia
Melrose Health
GooglePlay
Associated Press
Castran Gilbert
The Fortune Institute
Brisbane Times
Passage To India
The Royal Melbourne Hospital
Google
Green St Juice CO
Etihad Stadium
Instant RockStar
Windsorsmith
Crumpler
Novvi
Telstra
LBG Australia and New Zealand
Drupal
Fast.co
Positive Poster
SunSense Digital Agency
Carlton Football Club
Florsheim Shoes
Tribe
Melbourne Central
Plants
Garmin
Rock Pool Group
Magento
The Age
Microsoft Certified Azure Fundamentals
Chia
National Relay Services
Tek Ocean
Federation University Australia
Arc One
Palace Cinemas
Dial Before You Dig
CSquared Executive
MAP
Melbourne Sports and Aquatic Centre – MSAC
GPT Group
Ebay
National Museum of Australia
Moov Head Lice
Catholic Insurance
Tassal
AC/DC
Ubertas Group
Street Kitchen
Beaumont
131 Pizza
The Canberra Times
Coles
Rackspace
Xavier
Marshall White
Bigcommerce
Ello
DUSA, Deakin University Student Association
21st Century Australia Party
Liveoneday
BlackMores
James Buyer Advocates
Mecca Brands
Appstore
Paypal
Smart Company
Movember
Grow Your Business
Australian Anthill
High Street Armadale
CB Richard Ellis
SwinBurne University of Technology
OMS – Order Management System
Atlantic Group of Companies
Scrum.org
The University Of Melbourne
ABC
Mamma Lucia
Viktoria & Woods
Forbes
Kadac
MyAccount
Hairhouse Warehouse
ISO Certified

Testimonials

AndMine's Marketing Software ensures we stay on-brand no matter who in our office creates the campaign. We love that AndMine take all the IT complexity out of our online marketing so we can focus on results Emma Gleeson, QV Skincare

More Testimonials
AndMine-Google-Partner-Signature